Unlike American system, we have an integrated judicial system. We do not have judicial powers divided between center and states.
SC was inaugurated on 28th Jan, 1950. It succeeded Federal Court of India which was established in 1937.
System adopted from 1935 act.
Organisation
1 Chief
30 other judges
Originally, strength was fixed at 1+7 judges. Parliament has increased this by amendment.
Appointment
Prez does the job.
Senior-most SC judge is appointed as CJI (a per SC ruling in second judges case of 1993)
Other judges are appointed after consulting Chief. (Chief has to give his views after consulting a collegium of 4 senior-most judges)
Qualification of Judges
Organisation
Constitution has left it on the discretion of the President who fixes it from time to time depending on its workload.
Appointment
Prez does the job.
Chief of HC is appointed after consulting CJI and the governor of the concerned state.
Other judges are appointed after consulting CJI and the governor of the concerned state. and chief of HC . (Chief has to give his views after consulting a collegium of 2 very senior judges)
Qualification of Judges
Prez appoints under 2 circumstances for for a temporary period not exceeding 2 years
Acting Judges
Prez appoints
Retired Judges
At any time, chief can request any retired judge ofeither SC or HC to act as a judge for temporary period.
previous consent of Prez and the said judge is necessary.
Prez determines allowances.
SC was inaugurated on 28th Jan, 1950. It succeeded Federal Court of India which was established in 1937.
System adopted from 1935 act.
Supreme Court
Organisation
1 Chief
30 other judges
Originally, strength was fixed at 1+7 judges. Parliament has increased this by amendment.
Appointment
Prez does the job.
Senior-most SC judge is appointed as CJI (a per SC ruling in second judges case of 1993)
Other judges are appointed after consulting Chief. (Chief has to give his views after consulting a collegium of 4 senior-most judges)
Qualification of Judges
- Indian citizen
- should have been
- judge for HC(s) for 5 year OR
- advocate of HC(s) for 10 years OR
- a distinguished jurist in the opinion of Prez
Oath or Affirmation
by President or some person appointed by him.
Tenure of Judges
Constitution has fixed upper limit at 65 years. Any question regarding age is to be determined by such authority and manner as provided by the Parliament.
A judge can resign by addressing the letter to President.
Removal of Judges
Judges Enquiry Act (1968) has regulated the procedure by the process of impeachment
- A removal motion signed by at least 100 members in LS or 50 members in RS is to be given to the speaker/ chairman
- The speaker/ chairman may admit the motion or refuse to admit.
- If admitted, the speaker/chairman must constitute a 3 member committee to investigate the charges
- the 3 members need to be
- Chief or a judge of SC
- Chief justice of a HC
- a distinguished jurist
- If the committee finds that the judge is guilty of a) misbehaviour or b) incapacity, the house can take the motion for consideration
- After the motion is passed by each house by Special Majority, and address will be presented to the President (the address must be presented in the same session and it doesn't lapse with dissolution of LS)
- Finally, Prez passes an order and the judge stands removed.
Salary, Allowances, privileges, leave and pension are determined by Parliament and can not be varied to their disadvantage after appointment except in times of Financial emergency.
Pension is 50% of last drawn salary.
Ad-hoc Judge
Retired Judges
At any time, chief can request any retired judge of either SC or HC to act as a judge for temporary period.
previous consent of Prez and the said judge is necessary.
Prez determines allowances.
Constitution has declared Delhi as seat of SC, but it has authorized CJI to appoint other place or places as seat of SC (only with approval of the Prez). It is an optional provision.
With approval of President, SC can make rules governing procedure of the court.
at least 5 member benches for art. 143 references.
at least 3 member benches for other cases.
At any time, chief can request any retired judge of either SC or HC to act as a judge for temporary period.
previous consent of Prez and the said judge is necessary.
Prez determines allowances.
Constitution has declared Delhi as seat of SC, but it has authorized CJI to appoint other place or places as seat of SC (only with approval of the Prez). It is an optional provision.
With approval of President, SC can make rules governing procedure of the court.
at least 5 member benches for art. 143 references.
at least 3 member benches for other cases.
Independence of the court
- Appointment Procedure
- Removal Procedure
- Fixed service conditions
- Charged on consolidate fund of India
- conduct of judges cannot be discussed in legislatures
- Ban on practice after retirement
- Freedom to appoint own staff
- Power to punish for its contempt
- Jurisdiction cannot be curtailed (but can be widened by parliament)
- Separation from Executive
Jurisdiction and Power
- Original (and Exclusive)
- only a dispute involving a legal matter (not political or anything else) can be taken up under this
- no case involving any individual under this jurisdiction
- Exclusions
- Pre-constitutional treaties, covenants etc.
- inter-governmental treaties, agreements etc.
- Inter-state river water dispute
- matters referred to Finance commission
- adjustment of certain expenses and pension
- disputes of commercial nature
- recovery of damages by a state against center
- Writ (only original, not exclusive)
- between citizen and government
- types of writs
- habeas corpus
- mandamus
- prohibition
- certiorary
- quo-warrento
- Appellate
- on constitutional matters (HC certifies)
- civil matters
- criminal matters
- on special leave
- Advisory/ Consultative (from Canadian constitution)
- on a a question of law or fact of public importance
- not obligatory on SC to give opinion
- on any dispute arising out of pre-constitutional treaty etc
- obligatory on SC
- A court of record
- Power of Judicial Review
- Other Powers
- election of Prez, VP
- conducts and behaviour of UPSC members
- power to review own judgement
- ultimate interpreter of the constitution
- power of judicial superintendence and control
3 categories of advocates in SC
- Senior advocate
- Advocate-on-record
- Other advocates
High Court
Organisation
Constitution has left it on the discretion of the President who fixes it from time to time depending on its workload.
Appointment
Prez does the job.
Chief of HC is appointed after consulting CJI and the governor of the concerned state.
Other judges are appointed after consulting CJI and the governor of the concerned state. and chief of HC . (Chief has to give his views after consulting a collegium of 2 very senior judges)
Qualification of Judges
- Indian citizen
- should have been
- should have held judicial office for 10 years OR
- advocate of HC(s) for 10 years OR
a distinguished jurist in the opinion of Prez
Oath or Affirmation
by Governor or some person appointed by him.
Additional Judges
Tenure of Judges
Constitution has fixed upper limit at 62 years. Any question regarding age is to be determined by such authority and manner as provided by the Parliament.
A judge can resign by addressing the letter to President.
Removal of Judges
Judges Enquiry Act (1968) has regulated the procedure by the process of impeachment
- A removal motion signed by at least 100 members in LS or 50 members in RS is to be given to the speaker/ chairman
- The speaker/ chairman may admit the motion or refuse to admit.
- If admitted, the speaker/chairman must constitute a 3 member committee to investigate the charges
- the 3 members need to be
- Chief or a judge of SC
- Chief justice of a HC
- a distinguished jurist
- If the committee finds that the judge is guilty of a) misbehaviour or b) incapacity, the house can take the motion for consideration
- After the motion is passed by each house by Special Majority, and address will be presented to the President (the address must be presented in the same session and it doesn't lapse with dissolution of LS)
- Finally, Prez passes an order and the judge stands removed.
Salary, Allowances, privileges, leave and pension are determined by Parliament and can not be varied to their disadvantage after appointment except in times of Financial emergency.
Pension is 50% of last drawn salary.
Prez appoints under 2 circumstances for for a temporary period not exceeding 2 years
Acting Judges
Prez appoints
Retired Judges
At any time, chief can request any retired judge of
previous consent of Prez and the said judge is necessary.
Prez determines allowances.
Independence of the court
- Appointment Procedure
- Removal Procedure
- Fixed service conditions
- Charged on consolidate fund of India except that of pension (which is charged on consolidated fund of the state)
- conduct of judges cannot be discussed in legislatures
- Ban on practice after retirement (except in SC or other HCs)
- Freedom to appoint own staff
- Power to punish for its contempt
- Jurisdiction cannot be curtailed (but can be widened by parliament or state legislature)
- Separation from Executive
Jurisdiction and Power
- Original (and Exclusive)
- Writ (only original, not exclusive)
- wider than that of SC
- between citizen and government
- types of writs
- habeas corpus
- mandamus
- prohibition
- certiorary
- quo-warrento
- Appellate
on constitutional matters (HC certifies)- civil matters
- criminal matters
on special leave- Supervisory
- Control over subordinate courts
- A court of record
- Power of Judicial Review